Grimsby Telegraph's Gary Allen legal battle used in journalists' bible
THE legal battle by the Grimsby Telegraph to publicly name a dangerous sex offender has made it into print as a major training aid for other newspapers.
The case centres around Gary Allen, jailed for sexually assaulting and attacking sex workers just months after being cleared of the murder of a prostitute.
-

HIGHEST HONOUR: The Telegraph's case against Allen has been published in McNae's Essential Law For Journalists.
The Telegraph's legal battle to publicly name Allen as a warning to women in the town has been published in the latest edition of McNae's Essential Law For Journalists, the legal training bible for all journalists.
It was his move to Grimsby in April 2010 after being released from prison that led to a long legal fight by the Telegraph to name him and publish his picture to highlight the danger living in our community.
Business Cards From Only £10.95 Delivered www.myprint-247.co.uk
View detailsOur heavyweight cards have FREE UV silk coating, FREE next day delivery & VAT included. Choose from 1000's of pre-designed templates or upload your own artwork. Orders dispatched within 24hrs.
Terms: Visit our site for more products: Business Cards, Compliment Slips, Letterheads, Leaflets, Postcards, Posters & much more. All items are free next day delivery. www.myprint-247.co.uk
Contact: 01858 468192
Valid until: Wednesday, May 22 2013
In doing so, the Telegraph was taken to the High Court and accused of being in breach of the Contempt of Court Act.
The Telegraph's deputy editor, Michelle Hurst, said: "I worked for several months on the case, initially finding ways round court orders to name Allen, and then to defend our right to publish those details before a High Court judge – at considerable expense.
"Readers will remember that Allen claimed we had breached his human rights by publishing his name in relation to a Sexual Offences Prevention Order (SOPO) that stopped him from approaching prostitutes. To have the case printed in McNae's is one of the highest honours for a journalist, and will hopefully help other publications realise that there are ways to defend our right to publish matters of huge public importance, despite what the results of the Leveson Inquiry might bring."
The High Court judge backed the Telegraph at the time, throwing out Allen's claims and vindicating our coverage.
Allen left Grimsby soon after the publication, but was arrested days later for breaking his SOPO and attacking a police officer and returned to prison.
It is not known where he now lives.




3 Comments
by lashbaby
Saturday, March 09 2013, 1:38PM
“Tremendous piece of work by the telegraph, this man needs outing at every opportunity. If you wish to critisise I suggest you put him in Hull Daily Mail archive and study. I also hope you consider if you had a daughter experiencing difficult times and in a vunerable situation would you like her to encounter him.
Once again congratulations Michelle”
by richierich111
Saturday, March 09 2013, 11:48AM
“Michelle Hurst can't have done much in her journalistic career if she still finds it necessary to giver herself space in her own publication to rehash what could have turned out as an absolute disaster for the Grimsby Telegraph. Of course readers have only ever had one side of the story over the legal proceedings involving the naming if Mr Allen because Ms Hurst has editorial control of what goes into the newspaper and therefore what information the readers have.
In fact the Telegraph deliberately published a story and picture identifying Allen when a court had ordered them not to do so - simple fact. The use of the words in this article "finding ways round Court orders" tell the true story. I wonder whether the deputy editor would be crowing if Mr Allen had gone on the run as a result of his picture being plastered over the front page resulting in the police being unable to keep an eye on him and he'd as a result committed a further serious offence? Oh actually that was exactly what happened wasn't it? Even better if some local vigilantes had poured petrol through his letter box and people died as a result? Anyone remember the case of Alf Wilkins - acquitted by a jury and then burned to death in his own home by people who read about his case in the Telegraph but didn't find the fact he was not guilty buried in the small print?
As is regularly commented on this site the standards at this newspaper have slipped to such a disasterous extent that distinguished former staff members and editors no longer recognise the once proud local institution that the Grimsby Evening Telegraph once was.
Ms Hurst you should hang your head not be triumphant over your shabby part in this sordid case but you can of course rewrite history exactly as you want it.”
by harryX
Saturday, March 09 2013, 11:41AM
“"To have the case printed in McNae's is one of the highest honours for a journalist, and will hopefully help other publications realise that there are ways to defend our right to publish matters of huge public importance, despite what the results of the Leveson Inquiry might bring."
"...there are ways to defend our right to publish matters of huge public importance..."
I will save this and put it along side other clasics, such as the deputy head of fraud at the Crown Prosecution Service who said:
"People who commit fraud, in any walk of life, should know that the scale and technicality of a case is no barrier to bringing it to justice. At the heart of any complex fraud is a simple notion of dishonesty which is something that we can all understand." http://tinyurl.com/acjhhm6”