Video: Racing writer facing bankruptcy after ex-F1 driver's Porsche blows up

Trusted article source icon
Wednesday, January 23, 2013
Profile image for Grimsby Telegraph

Grimsby Telegraph

A MOTORING journalist claims he is facing bankruptcy after an ex-F1 racing driver sued him for blowing up a prize Porsche car.

Mark Hales, 62, of Fen Lane, Conisholme, was at the wheel of an iconic classic racing car when its engine blew up at Cadwell Park racing circuit.

  1. IN A SPIN:  Mark Hales with the Porsche 917 before its engine blew up. Inset, coverage at the time.

    IN A SPIN: Mark Hales with the Porsche 917 before its engine blew up. Inset, coverage at the time.

Mr Hales has now been ordered to pay nearly £50,000 to its owner, David Piper, after a top judge ruled the damage was the result of "driver error".

On top of the damages, Mr Hales, a freelance writer, said he is facing legal costs of £63,000.

Freeview aerials/ Freesat installs

Skyline

View details

Print voucher

Any freeview or freesat install for only £49 to one room, additional rooms £20 extra per room

Terms: Only covers standard install.

Contact: 01472800127

Valid until: Tuesday, December 31 2013

He told how he was humiliated after taking a Porsche 917 belonging to ex-Formula One driver Mr Piper for a spin in preparation for a magazine article in April 2009.

The engine of the green-and-white vintage motor – made from genuine Porsche parts and valued at £1.25 million – failed catastrophically as Mr Hales drove it around the course.

As we featured in the Grimsby Telegraph at the time, he was comparing Piper's Porsche with a £1.5 million Ferrari owned by Pink Floyd drummer Nick Mason, of which Mr Hales is the main driver.

Mr Piper, 82, sued Mr Hales, claiming the journalist had over-revved the engine – but Mr Hales said the gear jumped out, leading to the engine failure.

He said he understood there was a "verbal agreement over the phone" about who was responsible in the event of mechanical problems.

But Mr Piper was awarded £47,961.86 following an embittered and hard-fought hearing at London's High Court.

Judge Simon Brown QC said the evidence "overwhelmingly" pointed to the engine damage being caused by over-revving following Mr Hales' failure to properly engage gears.

He described the journalist as "a most unreliable witness whose evidence was creative, inconsistent, self-motivated and incredible".

But Mr Hales told the Grimsby Telegraph he felt the judgment and "gratuitous destruction" of his character was "unfair".

He claimed he had only done about 15 laps with the Porsche, which has since been sold.

He added: "The 917 was notoriously difficult. All the best drivers had problems and there were lots of engine failures; Vic Elford lost victory at Le Mans in his 917 because of the same problem.

"It looks like bankruptcy for me."

5
Tweet this article
Report

5 Comments

  • Profile image for PeteGy102

    by PeteGy102

    Wednesday, January 23 2013, 7:28PM

    “Theres quite a healthy thread on Pistonheads.com if anyone wants any more information.”

  • Profile image for Big-Hat-Harry

    by Big-Hat-Harry

    Wednesday, January 23 2013, 1:00PM

    “David Piper only competed in two or three F1 races. He was a sports car driver for Ferrari for more of his career. I guess this wouldn't make such a compelling headline though.

    Also, blowing up an engine is one of the risks of race car driving. It would seem that this is a vexatious prosecution.”

  • Profile image for TheWrangler

    by TheWrangler

    Wednesday, January 23 2013, 12:14PM

    “Agreed Malcom, but there are specialist policies for motoring journalist (or so google says) and if you did not have any insurance, then just get a signed full personal imdemnity prior to using it (not an unwitnessed verbal agreement, over the telephone!)

    So, like I said... if you are gonna risk it for a biscuit with a 1.5 million pound car, may as well go all in!”

  • Profile image for Malcolm_Ex

    by Malcolm_Ex

    Wednesday, January 23 2013, 10:52AM

    “Wrangler, think you would have a few problems getting insurance for mechanical problems on a £1.5 million car!”

  • Profile image for TheWrangler

    by TheWrangler

    Wednesday, January 23 2013, 9:45AM

    “What no insurance?

    Well if you are gonna risk it for a biscuit with a 1.5 million pound car, may as well go all in eh!”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article