VIDEO & VOTE: Is keeping the Ice Factory in its current state worth it?
TODAY we are asking you if keeping the Ice Factory in its current state is worth £1.5-million.
A firm of consultants has given a report to North East Lincolnshire Council detailing the cost of restoring the historic dock-side building.
-

As reported, the grade two listed factory closed 20 years ago. Now it is in danger of collapsing and English Heritage has placed it on its important buildings at risk register.
English Heritage team leader for Lincolnshire Catherine Dewar said the building is the earliest surviving ice factory in Britain, and the sole survivor from this period – so the group hopes to save the machinery.
On Thursday, the inaugural meeting of Grimsby Ice Factory steering group will be held to look at the future of the building.
var InSkinParams = new Array();
InSkinParams["srv_SectionID"] = "124017";
InSkinParams["srv_SectionIDPlay"] = "124010";
InSkinParams["srv_Keywords"] = "";
InSkinParams["srv_Categories"] = "";
InSkinParams["srv_UseSAS"] = "false";
InSkinParams["sas_PrerollAdTag"] = "";
InSkinParams["sas_PauseAdTag"] = "";
InSkinParams["sas_PlayAdTag"] = "";
InSkinParams["plr_InSkinID"] = "myInSkin1";
InSkinParams["plr_ContentID"] = "myContent1";
InSkinParams["plr_ContentW"] = "558";
InSkinParams["plr_ContentH"] = "358";
InSkinParams["plr_FrameTop"] = "60";
InSkinParams["plr_FrameSide"] = "30";
InSkinParams["plr_FrameBottom"] = "40";
InSkinParams["plr_InSkinW"] = "618";
InSkinParams["plr_InSkinH"] = "458";
InSkinParams["plr_TotalW"] = "900";
InSkinParams["plr_TotalH"] = "600";
InSkinParams["plr_ContentType"] = "JWFLV";
InSkinParams["plr_ExpandableDetached"] = "true";
eval("InSkinLoad."+"init(InSkinParams);");
Those campaigning to save it claim that to fully restore it would cost less than £10-million, while a "sticking-plaster" to preserve it in its current state would cost £1.5-million.
But is it worth it?
See today's Grimsby Telegraph for the arguments for and against.












62 Comments
View all
by A. Grimlander, GRIMLAND - where one ship counts
Thursday, July 22 2010, 9:19AM
“Yes, indeed Jo, we don't have any real control over English Heritage and we don't seem to have much control over the council, despite voting for them (unless you are a NOTA). Sadly, the council doesn't exercise its existing control over ABP which, as owner of the property, also has its rights. We have to ask, surely, "What's going on?" Or shouldn't the GT be asking, for us?
for a membership application or to make a donation. Contact the p.s.'Lincoln Castle' Trust via if you think you can contribute 'in kind', with expertise and labour, in the conservation and future use of OUR vesssel -- painters, scrapers, chippers, welders, fitters, joiners, teachers, lawyers, architects, engineers... and, not last, AND CERTAINLY NOT LEAST:... tea-ladies (and gents) sandwich-makers...
Fortunately, our much more publicly-accessible heritage structure -- the p.s. 'Lincoln Castle' could be available to you all, with a say in what its future should be. Contact the Lincoln Castle Preservation Society at
This is something where you can have direct input without having to deal with quangos and councils. The Society and the Trust are both beavering away in those directions on your behalf, but it ain't arf ard work!
Come on chaps. That ship is important, even nationally and internationally, and accessible to us all, unlike the 'ice factory'. If you want to see what THAT's really like, Google 'grimsby ice house -- or factory -- and see "squirrel"'s pictures...
Talk's cheap in relation to inaccessible ice plants. A little bit of dosh could make all the difference to the 'Lincoln Castle' and could show the world that despite councils and qangos, ordinary people CARE.”
by josephine white, Grimsby
Thursday, July 22 2010, 8:30AM
“I think what's most frustrating, is that we'll have no say or control over what happens to it either way.
It's a privately owned building (in as much as ABP is seemingly a law unto itself) and the decisions have probably already been made.
I don't know whether this story and poll were suggested to the GT by the Council, but often, straw polls like this are a way of sounding out how the public are going to react to decisions that have already been taken and which are about to be announced. It gives them fair warning of how to spin stuff to their best advantage.
What a sham democracy we live in.”
by walt.a.meattie, grimland with nearly nothing
Wednesday, July 21 2010, 9:47PM
“Dear me -- and everybody. Jo, Neil, me, all in agreement? wot's goin on!?
don't ask me why heritage organizations, both nationally and locally, like the talk-shop civic society, and english heritage, give more regard to a dilapidation of a privately owned building on private property with almost totally restricted public access than they do to a vessel that did far more for the local area's economic and social development with 100% public access throughout its working life than a hundred ice factories 'down dock' ever could have done!
let's face it, the ice factory made ice for trawlers; the trawlers were owned, largely, by local 'captains of industry'. The crews got little; the ice-workers got little; and the rest of the Grimbarians only got a small portion of what the workers spent locally.
However, the 'Lincoln Castle' and its railway line were important enough to the railway company and north-east Lincolnshire to escape the Beeching Axe when even the line to London, now known as Peaks Parkway, got the chop. You should see the frequency of trains and the frequency of stations on that short line from Cleethorpes to New Holland plus the little Barrow Haven/Barton spur. They are still there. So is the 'Lincoln Castle'. Just.
Make yor mark and it'll stay! There'll be nothing else in the historic Haven (a.k.a. Alexandra Dock - South Arm) wotteva the claptrap Masterplan says.”
by Trace, GY
Wednesday, July 21 2010, 7:10PM
“Restore the Ice House!! It has so much potential as a fishing and heritage museum. Our town is built on the dock and its community and this is where the heritage museum should be. I agree with turning the newer fishing heritage building into a more modern gallery, thus allowing new local artists an environment in which to display their talent as well as preserving what is a beautiful old building.”
by Lizzy, grimsby
Wednesday, July 21 2010, 8:11AM
“If the council had had the forsight to begin with when the ice house first became empty we would now have a fantastic museum and fishing heritage centre but no one on the council seems to have that. Instead we are left with a run down building and all our heritage and artifacts in a warehouse somewhere on a industrial estate where no one can see them. We also have a fishing heritage centre where when asked about our brave fishermen and the boats they sailed in don,t know the answers. So come on councillers if you think so much about our heritage get your finger out and prove it.”